Old-Fashioned Sub Sandwiches IN MENTOR, OH.

Family owned and operated.

Considered one of the hidden gems of Mentor, OH, Tommy’s Old-Fashioned Subs serves hot and cold sandwiches with only the freshest ingredients since 2008.

our signature subs

4.5 Inch: $4.99 • 8 Inch: $7.49 • 8 Inch Super: $9.49 • 16 Inch: $13.99 • 16 Inch Super: $16.99

Make any cold sub hot. Make any sub a wrap.

Cold Subs (4.5”/8”/16”)

  • Italian (Provolone, Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni)

  • Club (Provolone, Ham, Turkey, Bacon)

  • Ham + Cheese

  • Turkey + Cheese

  • Veggie

  • Roast Beef + Cheese

  • Capicola + Cheese

  • Salami + Cheese

  • Tuna

  • BLT

  • Super Club (Provolone, Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Bacon)

HOT SUBS (8”/16”)

  • Hot Italian

  • Italian Burger (Provolone, Salami, Capicola, Ground Beef)

  • BBQ Beef

  • Reuben

  • Meatball

  • Chicken Parmesan

  • Pizza (Provolone, Ham, Pepperoni)

PHILLY CHEESESTEAKS (8”/16”)

  • Philly Cheesesteak (Onion, Peppers, Mushroom, Mayo)

  • Super Philly (Extra Meat + Cheese)

  • Chicken Philly (Onion, Peppers, Mushroom, Mayo)

  • Super Chicken Philly (Extra Chicken, Cheese)

  • Buffalo Chicken

  • Bacon Chicken Ranch

WRAPS

  • Chicken Caesar

  • Turkey

  • Ham

  • Roast Beef

SALADS

  • Grilled Chicken

  • Buffalo Chicken

  • Chef

  • Tuna

drinks

  • Featuring Coke Products

SIDES

  • Chips

  • Cookies

homemade sides

  • Pasta Salad

  • Macaroni Salad

  • Potato Salad

“We're in Mentor, OH from Pittsburgh for a hockey tournament and found this place on Yelp. We usually try to avoid chain-type places, and this place is why. It ain't fancy, but our subs were so good. The sign in the window says ‘best subs in town’. It's not wrong.” — Lisa B.

“I'm not one to reach for subs often, but when my mom and I noticed this place today, we had to come in! An independent, mom and pop place with locally sourced ingredients, including buns freshly baked at a nearby bakery. She had the philly cheese steak and I had three corned beef reuben. SO good! We will definitely be back!” — Steph M.